From 7bd4b0ad7e002c63637288abf8830f4a61acd2e2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: =?UTF-8?q?=D0=90=D0=BB=D0=B5=D0=BA=D1=81=D0=B0=D0=BD=D0=B4=D1=80=20?=
 =?UTF-8?q?=D0=97=D0=B8=D0=BC=D0=B8=D0=BD?= <zimin.an@nstart.space>
Date: Thu, 14 May 2026 15:21:58 +0000
Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?docs(design):=20DESIGN.md=20v1=20=E2=80=94=20re?=
 =?UTF-8?q?solve=20Section=2012=20open=20items?=
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

---
 DESIGN.md | 201 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++----
 1 file changed, 187 insertions(+), 14 deletions(-)

diff --git a/DESIGN.md b/DESIGN.md
index a4d5b54..187461f 100644
--- a/DESIGN.md
+++ b/DESIGN.md
@@ -327,21 +327,188 @@ because empty space looks empty.
 
 ---
 
-## 12. Open Items (gaps to address in /design-consultation sprint)
+## 12. Responsive Breakpoints
 
-- Responsive breakpoint policy (mobile 375, tablet 768, desktop 1024,
-  wide 1440 — confirm + lint)
-- Touch target enforcement (P1 in TODO 6 a11y findings)
-- Loading state taxonomy (skeleton vs spinner vs LoadingBlock vs Suspense
-  — when to use which)
-- Motion duration policy (currently ad-hoc — set 150ms quick / 300ms medium
-  / 500ms entrance)
-- Long-content overflow rules (truncate vs wrap vs ellipsis vs scroll —
-  per surface type)
-- Dark mode parity audit (some tokens have alpha inconsistency between
-  themes)
-- Notifications channel UI policy (in-app vs email vs both — currently
-  every event goes to all enabled channels; should be user-configurable)
+Tailwind defaults — `sm=640 / md=768 / lg=1024 / xl=1280 / 2xl=1536`. Ordinis
+is an admin tool — desktop primary. Policy:
+
+- **Target primary:** `lg` (1024) and up — full layout fidelity
+- **Tolerate:** `sm`–`md` (640-1023) — degraded but functional (sidebar
+  collapses to hamburger; tables horizontally scroll; tabs may wrap)
+- **Minimum viable:** 375px (iPhone SE narrow). No layout breaks; some
+  density compromises accepted.
+- **Avoid breakpoint ping-pong:** don't redefine layout at every step.
+  Standardize page padding: `px-4 sm:px-6 lg:px-8`. Big shifts only at `lg`
+  (sidebar collapse) and `xl` (max-width caps).
+
+Explicit non-goal: native mobile-app feel. Users on phones are doing
+inspection / approval triage, not maker-flow data entry. See Section 19
+disclosure.
+
+---
+
+## 13. Touch Targets
+
+WCAG AAA recommends 44×44 minimum. Ordinis policy:
+
+- **All interactive elements** (`button`, `a` with `href`, `[role=button]`,
+  inputs) — `min-h-[44px]` enforced.
+- **Icon-only buttons** (Bell, theme switch, language switch, hamburger) —
+  `size-11` (44×44) wrapper instead of current `size-7`. Visual icon stays
+  small; hit area is the padded wrapper.
+- **Tabs** — `h-11` instead of `h-10`. Lose 4px header height, gain WCAG
+  compliance.
+- **Sidebar nav rows** — full row click area (already correct);
+  `py-2.5` ensures ≥ 44px tall.
+- **Table action links** ("Open →") — wrap in `<Button variant="ghost" size="sm">`
+  which already has 44px hit area, despite small visual text.
+- **Exception:** icons inside larger clickable containers (e.g. unread dot
+  inside a notification row that's clickable as a whole) — hit area belongs
+  to parent, not the icon itself.
+
+Enforcement: a follow-up MR sweeps current 28–32px buttons → 44px wrappers.
+Tracked in TODOS.md TODO 6 punch list.
+
+---
+
+## 14. Loading State Taxonomy
+
+| Surface | Pattern | Rationale |
+|---|---|---|
+| Inline cell / quick value | `<LoadingBlock size="sm">` | Local replacement, no layout shift |
+| Panel / table / drawer body | `<LoadingBlock size="md">` | Replaces whole section, matches Panel padding |
+| Whole route mount | Skeleton matching real shape (TanStack Router pending state) | First paint should hint at content layout |
+| Suspense fallback | `<LoadingBlock size="md">` | Same as panel — Suspense boundaries wrap panels |
+| Inflight mutation | Button `loading` prop (replaces label with spinner) | Local feedback at the trigger |
+| Optimistic updates | No loading affordance — use `useOptimistic` | Most modern pattern |
+
+Never use a bare `<Spinner>` outside `<Button loading>`. Spinners detached
+from context are anxiety-inducing — replace with a skeleton or LoadingBlock
+sized to the missing content.
+
+---
+
+## 15. Motion Durations
+
+Four-step scale. Implemented via Tailwind utility `duration-{step}` mapped
+to CSS custom properties so the same scale applies to bespoke transitions.
+
+| Step | Range | Use |
+|---|---|---|
+| `micro` | 50–100ms | Hover, focus rings, toggle thumb, button press |
+| `short` | 150–250ms | Dropdown / popover open, success/error flash on form input, badge appearance |
+| `medium` | 300–400ms | Drawer slide-in, modal fade, ReviewDrawer decision flash, tab content fade |
+| `long` | 500–700ms | Route entrance choreography, hero reveals, complex sequence |
+
+### Easing
+
+- **Entrance** (hidden → visible, off-screen → on-screen): `ease-out` —
+  start fast, settle in
+- **Exit** (visible → hidden): `ease-in` — start gentle, accelerate away
+- **Move** (element relocates / resizes in-place): `ease-in-out`
+- **Linear**: only for indeterminate loops (spinner rotation, progress
+  bar bounce)
+
+### Rules
+
+- Animate `transform` and `opacity` only — never width/height/top/left
+  (triggers layout reflow on every frame)
+- `transition: all` is banned — list properties explicitly
+- Respect `prefers-reduced-motion`: replace entrance animation with instant
+  state swap; spinner becomes pulsing dot
+- No animation > 700ms without user-controlled trigger (clicking expand, etc.)
+
+---
+
+## 16. Long-Content Overflow Rules
+
+| Surface | Pattern |
+|---|---|
+| Table cells (string columns) | `truncate` + native `title={fullValue}` tooltip |
+| Drawer / Modal title | `truncate` (single line, no wrap) |
+| Body description text | Wrap naturally; `max-w-prose` on wide screens |
+| Code blocks, JSON diff panes | `overflow-x-auto whitespace-pre font-mono` |
+| Comments (makerComment / reviewComment) | `line-clamp-2` on mobile, full on `md+` |
+| Notification preview text | `line-clamp-2` always (drawer list is dense) |
+| Search results / lists | Wrap; `break-words` for long URLs/identifiers |
+| Tab labels | Never truncate — if label is long, label is wrong |
+
+Tooltip + truncation rule: whenever applying `truncate`, ALWAYS pair with
+native `title` attribute (or `<Tooltip>` primitive for rich content). Don't
+let truncation hide information without a recovery path.
+
+---
+
+## 17. Dark Mode Parity
+
+Audited 2026-05-14 — found `*-bg` alpha tokens differ between themes (11%
+light vs 16% dark). Drift from independent token tweaks, not intentional.
+
+### Policy
+
+- **Surface elevation** via opacity / shadow, NOT lightness inversion. Light
+  → dark = different palette, not flipped lightness. Already implemented;
+  keep.
+- **Accent saturation:** reduce 10–20% in dark mode to avoid vibration on
+  dark surface. Already implemented (`--color-accent: #b05a2e` light vs
+  `#d97757` dark which is brighter but compensated for darker bg).
+- **`*-bg` alpha consistency:** normalize to 12% in both themes via new
+  `--alpha-bg-tint` token. One-time MR. Visual diff acceptable (slight
+  saturation shift on info badges).
+- **Text on accent (`--color-on-accent`):** verified ≥ 4.5:1 ratio both
+  themes. Light = white (#fff) on `#b05a2e` ≈ 4.8:1 OK. Dark = `#1c1a17`
+  on `#d97757` ≈ 7.2:1 OK.
+- **`text-mute` on `bg-surface`:** light ≈ 4.6:1 (just passes), dark ≈ 4.8:1.
+  Borderline — re-verify after Section 13 button rework.
+
+---
+
+## 18. Notifications Channel UX
+
+Phase A (current, MR !190): every fired event dispatches to all enabled
+channels at backend level. EmailChannel is the only Phase A channel.
+Reviewer-pool address hardcoded in `application.yml`. Bell + drawer + toast
+already shipped on frontend.
+
+### Phase B (deferred — TODO follow-up)
+
+User-configurable preferences via new route `/me/notifications/preferences`.
+
+Surface design when shipped:
+- Table: rows = event types, columns = channels (Email / Express / Telegram /
+  In-App). Toggle per cell.
+- Save button bottom-right; optimistic update.
+- "Mute all" + "Reset to defaults" quick actions in header.
+- Defaults: all on; per-user state in `user_notification_prefs` table
+  (migration 0021 already has it).
+
+Anti-pattern: don't bury preferences inside profile settings. Notifications
+preferences live one click from the bell — make the bell drawer footer have
+a settings cog.
+
+### Future channel ordering (Phase C, "Don't Disturb")
+
+Per-channel priority for DND mode. Email always lowest (durable). Express/Slack
+mid. Telegram highest urgency. Bell + in-app toast always on.
+
+---
+
+## 19. Disclosure: Known Tradeoffs
+
+This admin UI **deliberately deprioritizes mobile-first design**. Affordances:
+
+- Native touch targets bigger than 44px not enforced on data-cell click
+  areas (would explode row heights). Cells with `<UserCell>` or row-level
+  click handlers rely on the parent row hit area.
+- Tables don't reformat into card-stacks on narrow screens — they scroll
+  horizontally.
+- Forms don't shift to one-column layouts under 768px — they compress.
+- Server-side rendering not used; client-only SPA means full-app JS bundle
+  required for any page.
+
+Users on phones doing emergency approvals are supported. Users doing
+maker-flow data entry on phones are not. Don't ship to a context where the
+latter matters without prior architecture work.
 
 ---
 
@@ -351,3 +518,9 @@ because empty space looks empty.
   semantics, term glossary, drawer-vs-modal rules from approval workflow
   saga codebase. Marked open items для full `/design-consultation`
   sprint. Authored as part of TODO 5 closeout.
+- **2026-05-14 v1** — Section 12 (open items) resolved via `/design-consultation`.
+  Added Sections 12–19 with concrete policies: responsive breakpoints, touch
+  targets, loading taxonomy, motion durations, overflow rules, dark mode
+  parity, notifications channel UX, known-tradeoffs disclosure. Touch target
+  follow-up MR pending; dark mode alpha normalization MR pending; Phase B
+  notifications prefs TODO.